Steel toe shoes have a reputation for being robust, strong, and reliable in terms of safety and feet security. They have a stable and durable steel construction that can withstand any external impact and compression.
Contrarily, soft toe shoes are the kind of footwear that lack any toe caps made of solid materials like steel. They could be reinforced with other materials like rubber or other synthetic material.
Both kinds vary in terms of construction, safety, and comfort. So, should you buy best steel toe shoes or soft toe boots? Before coming to such a conclusion, you must know both sides of the story.
What is a Steel Toe Shoe?
Steel toe shoes are a type of protective footwear that has a steel construction. In other words, these boots have steel caps on their toe area.
As the toe boxes have a steel protective layer, your feet and toes remain protected from any sharp falling or penetrating objects.
Steel toe shoes are known for their durability and rugged nature. They can be used for years as they do not wear out quickly.
Such shoes are used by workers working in hazardous conditions like industries, factories, construction areas, etc. As they have other relevant safety features added to them, they are the ultimate choice for demanding workplaces. Thus, they are also known as steel toecaps, safety shoes, safety boots, steel-capped boots, etc.
It should be noted that steel toe shoes can conduct electricity due to their metal construction. Hence, it might not be a primary choice for electricians.
History of Steel Toe Shoes
Steel toe shoes have their origination in Germany. Towards the end of WWII, more number of people (soldiers and workers) were getting injured, especially on their feet. It was becoming a burden to replace the injured worker due to the increasing cost. This made way for a more reliable and practical option- steel toe shoes.
Major safety footwear brands like Red Wing, Skinheads, Dr. Martens, Grinders were entering the safety footwear market to meet the demands.
What is a Soft Toe?
Soft toe shoes are the type of footwear that does not have a steel or metal covering on the toe area. In place of a metal layer, composite materials like rubber or a thick fabric are used. Most of the time, uniform material is used for the entire shoes’ upper.
Unlike steel toe shoes, soft toe shoes do not have a robust material on the toe caps. The main intention behind such footwear is its universal applicability. Not all workers require metal safety covering. As some people work in less hazardous and civil conditions, they need not wear steel-toe shoes for their safety.
Not only are steel toe shoes expensive, but they also come with an added weight. Soft toe boots solve such an issue. These shoes have proven out to be a valuable alternative to heavy-duty safety boots.
They provide ample support as well as sufficient support. As steel toe shoes are conductors of electricity, you can use soft toe shoes if your job requires you to work with wires. Moreover, these shoes are metal detector-friendly.
Main Difference Between Steel Toe Shoes and Soft Toe Shoes
Besides the overall design and structure, there are several differences between steel toe shoes and soft toe shoes, like the following:
As the name suggests, steel toe shoes have a steel or metal covering over the toe caps.
On the other hand, soft toe shoes do not have a metal structure over the toe area. Instead, they have different composite material structures like rubber or thick and robust fabric.
There is less toe room provided in steel toe shoes, while there is plenty in soft toe shoes.
As steel toe shoes have a metal structure, they can set off metal detectors. If you work in a restricted workspace, you might want to skip this one.
Generally, soft toe shoes are made of rubber. This does not tick off metal detectors.
Steel toe shoes take the win when it comes to the safety factor. They have a hardened and robust covering around the toes to prevent any falling objects from hurting your feet.
If you work in factories or any such hazardous work conditions, you are prone to encounter accidents. It could be any heavy falling objects or sharp and penetrating substances. This could dangerously put your feet at risk. Steel-toe shoes can protect your feet from such repercussions.
As steel toe shoes are waterproof, you can use them in any weather condition. Moreover, they can protect you from any slipping accidents or electrical hazards.
Coming to soft toe shoes, as they lack any solid material structure, you should not use these in industrial areas. They might not be able to protect your feet from any such penetrating or puncturing objects.
However, they might protect you from any electrical hazards to an extent. They are also waterproof in nature. They have a reliable outsole, preventing any slippage or underfoot errors.
Steel toe shoes might be a pioneer in safety but lag in comfort levels. The steel construction adds weight that might wear you down. So, if you plan to wear your safety shoes for hours at length, steel toe shoes might not be the best option.
Due to the less toe room provided, your toes might feel cramped up without any wiggle room. This can result in blisters and toe pain.
But it’s not all stormy when it comes to the comfort aspect of steel-toe shoes. They provide adequate arch support, cushioning, and ideal fit.
Coming to the soft toe shoes, they have reinforced shanks with a generous amount of cushioning. This allows you to wear the shoes for long hours. Along with that, a sufficient amount of arch support is provided.
Most of the soft-toe shoes have a shock-resistant outer sole and ideal upper to comfort your feet. They might also have padded collars for an added comfort.
Steel toe shoes have more weight than soft toe shoes simply because of their construction. Even though this weight might feel negligible to some, it can impact some wearers.
If you plan to wear your shoes for an entire day, you can skip the steel toe shoes.
As soft toe shoes have a lightweight construction, it is easy to wear and carry them all day long.
Individually, steel toe shoes and soft toe shoes are expensive options. However, in comparison, steel toe shoes are cheaper than soft toe shoes.
As soft toe shoes can have composite construction, the prices may be more than steel material.
Which One is Better for Work?
After comparing both the shoe styles, it can be concluded that both types can be used for subjective work.
Steel toe shoes are applicable in hazardous work conditions, like manufacturing units, industries, factories, etc. As these shoes have a hardened and robust covering over the toe cap, it protects your feet and toes from any falling objects. In case any heavy metal object falls on your feet, the toe cap protects your feet and the bones.
Soft toe shoes lack a metal covering and hence not useful in dangerous workplaces.
Therefore, both the toe shoe styles have their specific and individualistic purpose that determines their usage.
If you are a factory worker in an accident-prone area, steel toe shoes are ideal. If not, soft toe shoes will work wonders!
Shoes differ in terms of color, shape, and purpose. But specific yet subtle differences like the toe style can make all the difference.
We hope that you have a better and enhanced idea about steel toe and soft toe shoes by now. Both styles have their individualistic purpose, and they are successful in fulfilling them.
Therefore, the next time you go on a shopping spree, keep the above-mentioned factors in mind and choose wisely!
I am a registered professional nurse with experience of 10+ years under my belt. I graduated from NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing with a Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN). Since then, I have been beneficial for various rehabilitative and critical medical situations. I work with Feetfitness.com Team with researching foot problems and assists them by providing my expertise in the best footwear for different medical conditions. I am also instrumental to the group by helping in test, compile, and present the best footwear for professionals & everyday uses